Interesting letter in Dear Abby today!

DEAR ABBY: I have recently found out that someone I thought was a good friend is the person who snitched and got my daughter in serious trouble at school. Our daughters attended the same preschool, middle school and high school. Although they were friends, the friendship was more between us moms.

Before middle school graduation, the students had an outing at the beach. Some of the girls, my daughter included, decided to bring vodka and orange juice. A few days later, my daughter was called to the principal’s office where she was thoroughly reprimanded. Any awards she was to receive were rescinded. I learned from one of the teachers that this “friend” is the person who turned her in.

Why didn’t she come to me and tell me? I almost feel like she wanted my daughter to get in trouble. I have run into her a couple of times and have been cold and distant, but I want to confront her. I was going to write and tell her why. Do you think this is a good idea? — FURIOUS IN FLORIDA

DEAR FURIOUS: I don’t blame you for being upset, but an eighth-grader bringing alcohol to a school celebration is wrong on many levels. I do not advise putting anything in writing. Convey your message and get the answer you want by doing it directly, face to face. (c) DEAR ABBY

That’s incomplete advice. Let’s take a closer look here. I’d wager anything that the letter writer’s daughter (let’s call her Laura) was at the beach with the letter writer’s friend’s daughter (let’s call her Jane). Laura brought alcohol and used peer pressure (on purpose or not) to get Jane to drink orange juice and vodka. Like, “Come on, we’re all doing it.” Or just with the implication going unstated of, you don’t want to drink any? Okay… be that way. You’re not cool. 

Jane’s mom found out about this, probably from Jane herself, and was righteously upset. Like, what the freak is going on here?! These kids are thirteen or fourteen years old.

Why didn’t she come to me and tell me? I almost feel like she wanted my daughter to get in trouble.

Yes, exactly. She wanted Laura to get in trouble, in large part because Laura deserved to get in trouble. The letter writer infers, by her above statement, that she wouldn’t have punished Laura on her own. It sounds like the perfect punishment was meted out: a stern lecture and no awards. I completely agree with this and approve of it. It seems a bit nontraditional due to how the bad behavior had nothing to do with school, but since we know Laura’s mom would’ve dropped the ball, it’s perfect.

I think Dear Abby gave lame, generic advice instead of delving into it more deeply.

3 thoughts on “Interesting letter in Dear Abby today!

  1. My own take on teenage drinking is that punishment is not a constructive response, but setting that aside, I wonder if the beach outing was an actual school field trip, or if it was a traditional everyone heads to the beach the weekend before grad kind of outing. Was Jane’s mom chaperoning an organized school outing, and that’s why she reported it to the school? Or did she hear it from Jane who heard it from Julie who heard it from Kevin’s dog who saw Laura was drinking?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Those are good points and good questions!! It’s frustrating that the letter writer didn’t give us more info. I took it as a trip to the beach made by the teens with no adults around, but you raise the interesting possibility that it was a school trip or something else. I wish letter writers knew that we need these details!! 😮 Good point about punishment, but I didn’t like the image I created in my mind of peer pressure… I could’ve been wrong about that too!! 😮

      But now I’m picturing a letter writer giving too much info: her middle name, astrological sign, favorite color, and the location of any bodily moles. Maybe I’m hoping for too much that they’d give us more info! 😀

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create your website with WordPress.com
Get started
%d bloggers like this: